Sunday 11 August 2024

Sunday at Barrys - Early WWII Western Desert Game in 15mm

 Today there were only four players (plus Barry as GM and Chris as observer) for an early (?) war game pitting the Brits (2 NZEF) against the Italians in the N African desert - no Germans were harmed in the playing of this game! Paul and I took the defending Italians while Andrew and John were the Kiwis. We did not really expect to win, but hoped to give the NZ Div a bit of pain before their additional numbers overwhelmed us. In the end, we actually did better than we expected, although if we had played on another 2 or 3 turns, we would doubtless have been wiped out!

The rules used were basically Andrew's home brew ones but with some tweaking by Barry, which added some complexity and removed some of the original concepts eg order changed from Rally, Fire, Move, Melee to Rally, Move, Fire, Melee - and the "return fire" that I quite liked from Andrews original idea was gone, but they seemed to work ok.


The view of the table from the south (Italians on the left)


And from the North - Italians on the right


Above and below - the built-up areas that the Italians had to defend to prevent a British victory



Above and below, the defending Italian force. Up to 4 airstrikes could be called up during the game.



Above and below, the attacking New Zealand forces - they also had 4 air strikes as well as off table artillery support (the Italian artillery was on the battlefield)



I am not very au fait with early war armour (or the Italians at all!) I think these are Vickers Mk VI - they are light tanks with small guns, anyway!


I believe these may be Valentines - medium tanks with a crappy 2lb gun!


Some kind of cruiser tank - again light armour and 2lb gun

The NZ-ers also had 6 Matilda II tanks - heavy armour but the same shit gun!


Hills placed under the cloth could be ascended by all troop types, hills on top (as above) could only be navigated by dismounted infantry, not wheeled or tracked vehicles


The Kiwis started 12" on from the table edge 


First blood to Italia as one of the Valentines was brewed up - molto bene!


The Regia Aeronautica puts in an appearance but to no effect this time - molto male!


The Kiwis had to test for bogging in soft sand every time they moved at full speed (3 x D6) If they rolled a 1, they were stuck. To represent the fact the Italians had been in situ for some time, they could move freely - as they knew where the bad going was - thanks, Barry! The black markers above indicate a couple of NZ tanks have run into soft sand!


Half the recon force of light tanks had the same issue!


On the next turn, the Italians sprung their surprise - an aggressive, forward defence! The two light tanks not bogged in soft sand were dispatched by AT fire - the Italians now lead 3 - 0.


The Kiwis came on in the same old way - and the Italians managed to continue to inflict losses on them, above and below.



The air force returned and this time, managed to knock out another NZ vehicle - by this stage, Paul and I were about 7 - 0 ahead.


But despite our early successes, there were still LOTS more where they came from 



Paul used the artillery to lay smoke to screen his light tanks from Johns Matilda's.


Over on the extreme left of the NZ advance, there was no Italian opposition


Once the smoke cleared, combined Kiwi fire took a heavy toll on Paul's armour


Andrew's artillery and a tank mounted howitzer had driven out most of the Italian garrison of my BUA by the time his infantry closed in - taking this position would give the Kiwis 3 VP


A couple of aerial views of the two BUA's we were defending



The Kiwi infantry made it into my BUA but the command element supported by a mortar, plus the one remaining infantry company, managed to push 2 of 3 NZ infantry companies back out again!


The last air attack by the Italians put some damage on the NZ infantry preparing to attack Paul's BUA


The central position from the NZ viewpoint


Despite the fact the Kiwis had made a good advance with their infantry, the Italians continued to whittle away their armour, gaining a VP for each vehicle destroyed. at this stage, it was 14 - 10 to the Italians......


Paul's command had been badly mauled by John - who had at least twice the fire power, so he should have been in the dominant position - my command was still reasonably intact but poor rolling meant I was firing 8 or 10 times but only knocking out one vehicle per turn.


In the final Kiwi turn, Andrews infantry managed to take my BUA at the second attempt, and then the RAF knocked out two of my vehicles


And the final score below - a narrow Kiwi victory - unlike the AB's against Argentina the night before LOL!



Now, in no particular order (that I am aware of!) are a whole bunch of eye candy close ups of the game from our gallant Kiwi opponent John





































Thanks for dropping by and hope you found the AAR of interest - despite playing on the losing side, I felt Paul, and I, held our own and was not too upset to lose by 1 point, given the imbalance of forces involved. Shame we had no managed to hold onto my BUA, that would have won us the game, but it was close enough to feel like a moral victory!

32 comments:

  1. Great looking game Keith.
    Solid Italian effort by you and Paul.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Cheers Ben - it was an enjoyable game, and we certainly made the Kiwis fight for the ground they gained!

      Delete
  2. Lovely looking game and a hard fought battle, some great miniatures and terrain on show. I must admit I like the early war armour, little tanks and small guns, much more interesting then the big all powerful ones of the later war.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for your visit and comments Donnie. I think a lot of people feel the same re the early war - the Brits in particular seem to have had a panoply of interesting looking light and "cruiser" tanks in the thirties and early forties.

      Delete
  3. Good stuff, Keith! Like Donnie, I like the early war period but NZ v Italy is not a match up seen often. A lot of great looking in-game photos to enjoy. To me, your Vickers tanks look like M3 Stuarts.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Jon, Barry has always been particularly interested in NZ military history, so he has Maori Wars stuff too, as well as early, mid and late WWII forces. Glad you appreciated all the pics too.

      Delete
  4. Fun report. The early war in the desert is an overlooked gaming subject, in my view, and really interesting. Good to see a game that featured the Italians as well--early war, their equipment was probably on a par with anything the Commonwealth had.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Ed, and re the equipment, you are correct....in fact, our tank guns were mainly superior...47mm v 2lb....and apart from the Matilda II, their armour was on a par as well, even though some of them looked tiny compared with the British vehicles.

      Delete
  5. That does look a great game Keith!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Ray - both your comments (see below) have just been released from the spam holding cell - dunno why!

      Delete
  6. Great game there Keith and I used to have loads of those FoW British figures before I downsized to 10mm. A moral victory for sure for the Italians. One day I would like to do some Western Desert stuff again, but it would mean a lot of new terrain, talk less of forces for both sides...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for your support on the result Steve! One advantage we have is that several members of our group were share holders/ directors of the company that initially set up Battle Front, so they were able to collect large forces of the 15mm stuff in whatever Era of the war interested them! Even I, simply doing some part time parts packing twenty years ago, have large German, Russian and British forces....most of which have rarely if ever been on an actual table!

      Delete
  7. A great looking game and a very close result. Those patrolling RAF planes did well knocking out two vehicles, and I see the Italians managed only one and missed out totally on the first sortie.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Lawrence, surprisingly, the real killer was a battery of four 3" mortars, which were just as effective as a dedicated anti tank weapon in taking out vehicles...I think that rule may need to be tweaked a bit!
      I can't recall exactly how well the Italian airforce did, but they certainly did not knock out more than a couple of vehicles. I made an error using them against the infantry in the last mission, I should have gone for armour or field guns, might have managed to add a VP or two to our final score 🤔

      Delete
  8. A very nice tabletop setup and a close enjoyable game by the sounds of it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Peter and yes, some nice scenic touches in this game, for sure - plus a neck and neck finish

      Delete
  9. Superb looking game. I think the North Africa theatre is my favourite for ww2. I live early war armour

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Cheers Scotty, for some reason N Africa never really "inspired" me, despite the 8th Army and Afrika Korps being amongst the first Airfix OO/HO figures I ever had, back in the dawn of recorded history! I must admit, I do like all the quirky vehicles, particularly the range of attractive but basically useless British light and cruiser tanks!

      Delete
  10. Cool looking game Keith, you played a blinder, but it wasn't to be? I do like the Desert War, it my fav WWII period. Why oh why did I sell all my figures!!!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Just released from the spam cell Ray - and this is a perfect example of why I have got rid of virtually nothing over the last twenty years, despite having collections that have not seen the table in anger for a decade or longer!

      Delete
  11. Moral victories are TECHNICALLY still victories.
    Are these 15s? somehow they look smaller, like 10s.
    Most games that are won / loss in the last turn are the ones that were fun to play. 😁

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Several very good points here Stew, all of which I agree with!
      Some of the early war armour is pretty diminutive, maybe that's why they look like a smaller scale?

      Delete
  12. Lovely looking battle Keith, I like seeing all that early war armour with rubbish guns 👍

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Matt, considering we only needed 9 (or sometimes 8) on 2 D6 to score a hit, we certainly managed to replicate the "rubbish guns" element of this period of the war! Paul and I thought we had no show but actually, we very nearly snatched a victory - a fun game in the end!

      Delete
  13. Good looking early war virtual victory for the Italians!
    Best Iain

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Iain....virtual victory, I like that!

      Delete
  14. Great looking W. Desert gaming, Keith! Love the look of those 15mm figures and vehicles. Never go into that scale, although I used to ogle the Flames of War kits at the local hobby store many years ago.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Dean, glad you like the effect of the 15mm kit. These are all "first generation " style ie solid resin bodies with separate turrets and cast metal tracks and guns....now, as far as I know, everything is hard plastic

      Delete
  15. That was a marvellous game/table/figures and vehicles. Plenty of combined arms and a close game too. Beautifully photographed, Keith!
    Top stuff.
    Regards, James

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks James, seems like the AAR hit all the right spots for you!

      Delete