Sunday 18 October 2020

Face to face gaming - The First Carlist War

Today the group got together for our first Face to Face game at Barry’s place for a couple of months. The era chosen as the First Carlist war 1830ish - Barry, Rick and I took the loyalist Isabellina forces, comprising Spanish, French Foreign Legion and British Auxiliary Legion troops, whilst Mark, Paul and Chris took the Carlist forces of the pretender to the throne.

The Carlists were holding a small town on the far side of a river that was fordable at all points for everything except wheeled guns. The Isabellinists aim was to take the town.

Our plan (mine mainly as Rick was a dissenting opinion) was to concentrate as many units as possible in the left centre of our side of the table and attempt to refuse our right flank, held by Barry with our best troops – FFL and the Spanish Guards (who were classed as trained, whereas most of the other troops on both sides were raw). I would lead the attack with the BAL – four raw battalions and one small battalion of British Royal Marines supported by a small battery, a troop of cavalry and a rocket battery. We were prepared to lose this command to pave the way for a secondary assault across the river by Barry’s command. Rick was on the extreme left flank with most of our cavalry, not the best position as he was confronted by a densely wooded area.

On the other side, Paul was occupying the woods opposite Rick on the Carlist right, Chris held the centre and Mark had the cavalry and some infantry on the left wing with the empty half of the table to exploit with his horsemen.

Rick struggled to get going with a number of poor activation rolls and did not get to grips with Paul until well into the second half of the game. For some reason, the Carlists were allowed to deploy a brigade well forward, on our side of the river and this hampered Barry’s movement from the start. The advance across the central plane under constant artillery fire went as well as could be expected and our support fire from guns and rockets whittled down Chris’s defending forces. Marks sweeping advance across the empty half of the table meant Barry had to deploy a number of units in a defensive screen but it proved to be insufficient, and Chris added to his discomfort with the brigade that had started on lour side of the river.

It was basically a battle of attrition where both Barry and I got to a point where under the rules, we were required to do a brigade morale test on the same turn and we both failed. This left Paul in a very bad state as Rick had the upper hand, the majority of Chris’s command gone from the field, but Mark coming in from Ricks rear with several units of fresh cavalry. As with many games, the dice decided things in the end – if Barry and I had held on another move or two, we might possibly have crossed the river and taken the town.

 
 

Initial layout showing the town on the far side of the river – all buildings scratch built by Mark

 

The Isabellinist deployment on the left of the road dissecting the battlefield

 

My command – troops are all mine bar the gun, Royal Marines (at rear), cavalry squadron and officers

 

The Carlist force defending the small town that was our objective

 

Barry deploys in a defensive posture – note Chris’s Carlist troops in the middle distance – they started the game occupying the small built up area

 

Pauls forces moving through the woods to confront Rick

 

Marks infantry cross the river on the Carlist left to march against Barry

 

First line of the BAL brigade close in on the river

 

The FFL wait for the Carlist onslaught

 

Close up of some of the FFL figures – everything we used in the game bar my four BAL battalions were supplied by Mark

 

Rick finally got some decent activation rolls and managed to deploy to engage Paul on our left flank

The wide open space on our right that was exploited by Mark with the Carlist cavalry

 

The BAL Scots battalion fires at the Carlist defenders across the river

 

The Carlist defenders advanced across the river and engaged in a close range fire fight with my BAL brigade. The eventual outcome was one Carlist unit quit the field, another routed and the third pulled back, but they did some damage to my units too

The struggle in the woods was going Ricks way for sure

This looks impressive for the Isabellinists, but in reality, all the troops in this image were on their last legs..

…as can be seen in the next image, where a couple of our units have quit the field

Rick was triumphant in his fight with Paul and was all ready to throw some cavalry across the river to complete his victory….


….but Barry and I both needed a brigade morale roll of 6 to hang about – and this time, both of us failed.

 


One more work week to go – then a three day public holiday weekend, Labour day here in NZ – and then we are off to Lake Tarawera by Rotorua in the central N Island for our week long annual wargaming retreat – yeeha!

 

22 comments:

  1. That's a lovely looking game Keith, with great figures and love the scratch built buildings. FtF gaming? Only something I can dream of at present:(. Have fun at your annual wargaming retreat and if you can, take some nice pics etc so we can vicariously enjoy your games!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Steve - yes we are pretty lucky here although midway through the day I got a text from my wife saying we had one new case of community transmitted Covid in NZ so fingers crossed that does not mean any travel restrictions....assuming the week away goes ahead, I will have LOTS of photos - and so will Mark on 1866 and all That!

      Delete
  2. Looks great Keith, always nice to get some mass ranks on the table...
    Wargamers retreat now that sounds better than Christmas... :-)
    Cheers
    Stu

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Stu - yes big games are great. Better than Christmas? A bit controversial I guess but from my personal point of view with a very small family and two grown up kids, I would say I agree 100%! If I had to choose between this week away or an overseas holiday, I would have to think twice about which I would prefer to do....

      Delete
  3. Hi Kieth- Wow! That is certainly a rather large battle. Good to see you folks enjoying a game together. Enjoy your Retreat too. Regards. KEV.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks KEV. By our group standards, this was quite a small number of figures. I had one brigade of five battalions....at Tarawera, I am likely to have twelve or sixteen battalions in a day long game!

      Delete
  4. What a great looking game Keith, I've always fancied doing the Carlist War myself........one day?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Ray. It's a very colourful period...we are very lucky to have Mark in our group..he has bought and painted both sides for several interesting eras...Carlist, Napoleon in Egypt and currently the Great Paraguyan War (I think..South America anyway)

      Delete
  5. Outstanding battle account, Keith! Sounds as if initial deployments and the dice may have decided this action early on. A day gaming with friends must have been very enjoyable even in defeat. Your annual Wargaming holiday is going forward this year? You are very lucky. I look forward to reading all of your holiday battle accounts.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Jonathan. Rick would certainly agree with you about our deployment, he was vehemently opposed to leaving the right hand side of our line devoid of troops, but if we had spread them along the entire line, we would have been too weak to assault through the centre to take the town...which was our objective! Problems, problems...maybe we wil get it right next time?

      Delete
  6. Very cool looking game with beautifully painted figures. Not familiar with this war, but the various armies concerned sounds very interesting.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you Dean - a pretty obscure war to be fair - I am sure we are only playing it because the Perry's made figures for it! I think basically it happened because the previous king changed the inheritance rules so his daughter could become queen, rather than his nearest male relative becoming king. Isabella was the queen and Carl the pretender to the throne. Fun fact - the French Foreign Legion - Legion Etrangere - was created to allow France to take part by proxy - it was after this war finished that the Legion first went to French North Africa!

      Delete
  7. Great looking game even if the result didn't go your way! Mark's scratch built buildings are ace aren't they?
    Best Iain

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Iain - it was nice that Rick did so well against Paul, as usually, he has terrible luck with dice rolling. Our plan failed but it was still the best option available I think - a bit of luck and we might have pulled it off! Marks buildings certainly are outstanding.

      Delete
  8. A lovely looking and sounding game Keith...
    Also a really colourful and interesting period...

    All the best. Aly

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Cheers Aly - Yes kit kept us entertained for a few hours and it is a nice period - Brits in bell topped shakos look very nice, like a Lady Butler painting!

      Delete
  9. Great-looking game Keith. Nothing worse than when an entire brigade crumbles like that, and even worse when it happens to two simultaneously.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Lawrence - yes it was a bitter pill but to be fair, I think I got away with it a couple of times before failing the third activation after I reached the critical point, so we probably held on longer than we should have. Chris and Paul also had to make similar rolls, so with different scores, we could have seen 4 of the 6 commands quit the field, which I think would have been a fair reflection of the game! If kit had been TtS with coins being lost, I am sure the Carlists would have been down to their last handful too,,,

      Delete
  10. Fantastic game Keith with beautiful terrain and mini. And such a motley composition of troops I'd call sworn friends :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Dmitry - the armies certainly are composed of many different nationalities!

      Delete
  11. What a marvellous looking game. A really interesting mix of colourful units, add some fabulous buildings and voilà, a magnificent looking table!
    Regarda, James

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you very much indeed James, hopefully, more of a similar vein when we are away next week on our annual wargaming trip!

      Delete