My regular gaming host Julian has a new project - he is going to get a few boxes of Perry Napoleonic plastic figures and make them up as individual figures for use with Too Fat Lardies Sharp Practice "large scale" skirmish rules.
As a first step, he and I set up a game on Thursday evening to try and work our way through how the rules function. We have previously (about three years ago) played a series of games using Chain of Command - so some of the mechanisms were familiar - but it took us the best part of four hours to stumble our way through the first game, with many errors made and ironed out along the way - here are a few pics and a brief report. We used some of Julian's 25 year old Front Rank French and Indian Wars figures and only the Native Americans (or should they be Native Canadians - maybe First Nation is safer??!) were individually based. It was not hard to overcome this although the aesthetics of "units" based in regular stands of threes lulled us into the mistake that Regular troops were per se "Units" when in fact, they are not unless two groups are combined together - this has some implications in the rules that we missed for about half of the game!
Initial layout from my side of the table - I had two bands of Indians (I mean First Nation Warriors....) two Troupes de la Marine Regulars, and one Coureur de Bois militia - Julian had two Regular Infantry units, Rogers Rangers and two units of militia.
The Indigenous warriors in some woods
Rogers Rangers - the SAS of the 18th century (apparently!)
Two "groups" of redcoats combined into a unit under the command of a "leader" The white card indicates they have been given a "present" order, which improves control over firing and adds hit bonuses. Only regular troops in combined units can take advantage of this order.
Front Rank Woodland Indians close up and personal
My Coureur de Bois unit pulverised Julian's first militia unit with in the opposite woods
One of the Native leaders was put hors de combat in the third or fourth move, so the other one took over command of both units.
Close up of one of my French officers - a very nice Front Rank figure
Julian's unhappy militia with 5 dead and a pile of shock markers - just after I took this image they routed 15" to the edge of the table and remained there for the rest of the game.
The regulars fire a controlled volley at the natives to their front - they had a "unexpected event" occur and this caused the smoke to hang around for the rest of the game, obscuring the battlefield and reducing their fire effectiveness by one!
A length ways view down the battlefield, my French force to the right. Units are numbered - the blue 4 indicates it is the French no 4 units turn to do something.
Troupes de la Marine and Coureur de Bois in the woods opposite Julian's militia (below)
That was it - I drove off one unit of Julian's militia and he killed one of my officers, we didn't get to have any hand to hand (called "Fisticuffs" in the TFL's usual tongue in cheek manner) because to come out of the woods and close with the enemy would have probably been suicidal!
A good game - quite a lot to the rules as I mentioned, so we got quite a few things wrong but by the end we felt we had worked out most of the key aspects - a rerun is scheduled for next week so hopefully we do better next time!
A couple of days ago, I emailed The Assault Group just to let them know the figures they sent me on 22 Dec had not yet arrived and today they replied. Very sportingly, Pete the guy at TAG said they would start packing a replacement order for dispatch in a few days and said they would use UPS rather than Royal Mail this time. However, I arrived home this evening to find the original parcel had arrived, so have let TAG know all is well.
I really must acknowledge TAG again for how good a deal their postage is - spend around £58 and postage is FREE anywhere in the world - that's £16.45 value on this package - compare that with some companies who charge 50% of the order value to the RoW, regardless of the actual postage cost they incur - a great company to deal with!
The first box contained 5 packs - 3 x 4 of Border Reivers and 2 x 4 of Border Militia Calivermen firing
The second box contained the "Unit Builder" deal I bought - 1 x 4 Border Militia Command and 5 x 4 Border Militia Calvermen.
These are all intended for our Border Reivers skirmish project, when it eventually comes to fruition. The Militia will be used as "regular" troops loosely under the control of "central government" (such as it was). Julian actually has a few Reivers himself, so mention was made last night of the possibility of giving THOSE an outing in a couple of weeks, after the second Sharp Practice game!
Finally, the following two images were taken out our back window a couple of hours after last weekends "sunny walk" images - not quite up to the standards of Storm Christoph of course, but just wanted to let readers know that it is not all milk and honey here!
I have Sharp Practice and am keen for a game, but have not delved into the rules as yet. Did you find them enjoyable? I'm still waiting for a Perry order placed around the same time as your TAG order, but I would guess the Christmas rush slowed things down a lot.
ReplyDeleteHi Lawrence - it was very much a learning game so hard to classify the rules but yes, I would say they had potential and once we get a few games under our belts, should give us some fun encounters. They will probably work better when we have individually based figures as intended, rather than more traditionally based units
DeleteI have SP too but have yet to try them out. I enjoy CoC so if they are similar, perhaps, I should blow he dust off the shelf and see what is what. For skirmish-style gaming, I have been enjoying Rebels and Patriots. R&P is relatively simple and easy to keep most rules in-head.
DeleteGlad to see your TAG order arrived. The holiday sale was a good one. I am still waiting for part of a Caliver Books order to arrive.
Thanks Jonathan. I might look into Rebels and Patriots...although, do I need yet another set of rules?! I was impressed the TAG guys immediately offered to send a replacement, given the postal issues are not their responsibility. It matches the statement on their site that says they will do this in the event of any issues and that they have never had a customer order not be fulfilled!
DeleteR&P is on the low end of complexity and provides a quick skirmish game. that is great customer service from TAG. I wonder what luck I may have from Caliver???
DeleteThey have been pretty good with me Jonathan...plenty of Comms and good service...their problem is, I don't think they hold a lot of stock, so they order it in once you make your order to them so they are reliant on other suppliers....I once waited weeks because they were waiting for Knucklrduster figures from the US and my latest order was delayed waiting for Nick Eyre at Northstar to supply them with some stuff!
DeleteNice post.... I am a big fan of SP for me they strike the right balance between skirmish and mass battles, shock can be a real a bugger if you have lots of Status I officers... surprisingly I found Chain of Command to be slightly more confusing, against an experienced player you can be beaten by others knowing technicalities within the rules, whilst SP still feels balanced regardless of experience.
DeleteCheers
Stu
Good looking game have thought about changing rules to chain of command etc but when you know a set it is hard to swop. I bet that rain is warm though !
ReplyDeleteCheers Matt - I guess one of the dubious advantages of our styule of gaming is that we try so many different rule sets, we never get to know any of them well enough that it is a hassle to move on to the next set. I honestly could not list all the different sets Julian and I have used over the years - the ones we stuck at for a while include Habitants and Highlanders from Canadian Wargames Group, Crossfire for WW2 15mm and more recently To the Strongest. Sometimes, we have literally played ONE game of a rule set and then never used them again - and not because we did not like them - its just Julian keeps finding another set he would like to try!
DeleteYes - the rain IS warm - and the wind too! Quite a strange feeling, even after 30 years here, to have gale force wind blowing in your face and its like standing in front of a heat pump!
DeleteI have just become accustomed to bolt action and it’s fairly simple approach. The wind and rain here in Cumbria is of a different quality !
DeleteA good set of rules and give a much better game than CoC IMHO. However I prefer Rebels & Patriots as they are simpler and easier to play pick up games. Also the broadly similar mechanics across all of Dan Mersey's Osprey rules make it very easy to switch from one to another, which is much more important to me these days.
ReplyDeleteThanks for the info and comment Steve. I have recently picked up the Osprey rule set "En Garde" with a view to maybe expanding the Renaissance skirmish project into a Three Musketeers collection ......
DeleteNice looking dipping of the toe into the new rules, it seems the experience of many is it has a steep learning curve, but that once mastered is popular. I like the charm of the Front Rank figure.
ReplyDeleteGood for shouting up for TAG ..... I am off to their website now!
Thanks Norm..hopefully we can get our heads around the core mechanics quite quickly and we can then stick with the one rule set for a whole...I would prefer to play using rules I just "knew", without having to look everything up every two minutes! Yes TAG deserve some support in my opinion so I hope you find something to tempt you on their site!
DeleteGreat looking terrain and troops, Keith. So, it's now French and First Nation War, F&FN war? Nice TAG figures too!
ReplyDeleteWell, unless the moniker "French" offends someone too...
DeleteThanks Dean. I think you may be overly kind, the table is pretty basic compared with our normal fare but it was only a learning exercise. The Front Rank figures have stood the test of time well and are still one of my favourite ranges.
DeleteJonathan, it's generally only the English who are offended by the French...they have been that way since at least 1066!
DeleteNice game with great miniatures! The UPS is not very convenient to use. I was forced to fill out a customs declaration for the parcel. 3 hours of painstaking work by typing in smartphone.
ReplyDeleteThanks Dmitry...I won't have to worry about UPS as the original package turned up! Most companies seem to us the local postal service and I have always found them fine. I even bought some figures from Siberia Miniatures and was able to track them all across eastern Russia before thy departed by air. One day, I hope to get some STP figures too!
DeleteFun looking game, nice front rank officer, I'm pretty lazy on new rules front to be honest! TAG service sounds great, I had to wait quite a long time for a Perry order before Christmas but it would have been 8 really busy time, I've had Osprey replace 4 books lost in lockdown post which was good of them also!
ReplyDeleteBest Iain
Cheers Iain...I am in your camp when it comes to rules...get one set you like, learn them so they are second nature, then stick to them ....it's worked for football! ( by which I mean "the beautiful game"....not that hybrid rugby version played in the Land of the Free)
DeleteA nice looking game Keith...
ReplyDeleteI have always found TAG’s service to be excellent...
I bet your rain was warm 😂
All the best. Aly
Thanks Aly...yes TAG have been pretty good to me so far.
DeleteFun! I’ve played a couple of games of SP2 and it’s a pretty good game set. It’s more complicated than it looks though, If you watch some of the play throughs on YouTube even the authors get the rules mixed up. 😀
ReplyDeleteI keep meaning to have a few ACW games with it but you know how it goes....
Thanks Stew...yes there was certainly plenty of complexity...enough to keep Julian and me checking the rule book every few minutes anyway!
Delete