Saturday, 3 August 2024

Friday night Russo - Polish War 1920

 With our genial host Julian FINALLY back from his extended European tour, Chris, Paul, John, Rick and I turned up on Friday evening for a game of Red Actions, pitting Russian Bolsheviks against the Poles.

As it had been my idea and I had brought along my RCW Bolsheviks, some of my figures made it onto the table - primarily cavalry, augmented from Julians own collection, as the scenario called for an all-cavalry Bolshevik force to assault a strategically important Polish village - as soon as I saw the table and Julian gave us the pre-game briefing, I thought we were in for a hard slog, and so it proved!


Initial layout - ten Bolshevik cavalry units, two groups of three and one of four, each with a Tchanka cart-mounted MG for "support" and a horse gun in the centre. The Poles had local peasant militia infantry in both woods plus regulars supported by a mortar, a field gun and a couple of HMG's in the centre. Three more Polish regular battalions were arriving as reinforcements in the top right of this image


I had a command of three cavalry units, a Tchanka and our sole artillery piece. With a congested front and insufficient room on either flank, I advanced straight towards the Poles!


To my left, John also advanced and was soon in contact with the first batch of Polish militia


The Polish militia are by Siberia Miniatures and are self-described as "caricatures" by the manufacturer. Some very interesting sculpts and poses, including a "pet" bear!


Paul's regular Polish infantry man the fence line.


There was another unit of Poles, supported by an HMG and field gun, in my line of advance.


Johns' cavalry goes in ......


..... and win the day!


I had dismounted 2/3 of my cavalry and had them advancing "evasively" (the "E"!) but they still accumulated hits (or "terror" markers) each turn.... the leading unit has already lost one base 😕


To my right, Rick also charged into the woods, pushing back the local militia unit there, too!


Meanwhile, Chris maneuvered his three battalions of regulars up to confront Ricks Cossacks. 


As seen from the Polish perspective - all my cavalry and most of Johns had dismounted - the Tchanka's were knocked out pretty easily and early on, so we had no MG support and the gun was initially hit and forced to retire, then, struggled to find a suitable position from which to target the Poles.



The Red right flank (Rick) with my dismounted troopers in the centre


Ricks Cossacks have another go at the peasant militia .....


.....  and drive them back, with loss!


The woods full of Bolshevik troops (mine and Ricks!)


The centre and left were pretty much a stale mate, the Poles were too strong for John to advance against them in the open


Rick put in a couple more charges on our right flank, but Chris easily repulsed them.

And that was the game, basically. Julian had included the possibility of Polish cavalry arriving as reinforcements, but they obviously were not required, as we Bolsheviks did not even come close to breaking the Polish infantry - apart from the field gun (which was eventually destroyed by Paul in Polish counter battery fire), I don't think any of my command ever actually fired their weapons - my Tchanka came on, did a U turn to get into position to fire, and was then hit twice and removed from play! Ricks lasted a bit longer but was about as effective, and John kept his out of the way, so it survived - but as a result, I don't think it ever fired - they are not particularly useful weapons for an attacker!

So, on this occasion, the Red Horde of the Konarmiya (конная армия) was driven off with heavy loss by the stout-hearted Poles!

Here is a short piece (courtesy of Wikipedia, of course), about the background to this scenario:

South-Western Front: the war against Poland (1920)

In 1920 Budyonny's 1st Cavalry Army took part in the Bolshevik defence against Poland's invasion of the Ukraine during the Polish-Bolshevik War, at first with remarkable success. The 1st Cavalry Army pushed Polish forces out of Ukraine and broke through the Polish southern frontlines, but later was bogged down at Lvov. This in turn led to a heavy defeat of the rest of the Bolshevik forces in the Battle of Warsaw. When Budyonny's Cavalry finally joined the battle, it was also soundly defeated in the Battle of Komarów, known as the last great cavalry battle in history. At this point, the 1st Cavalry Army's morale and discipline were at a low point, and robbery and violence against the civilian population became commonplace.  The 1st Cavalry Army also became known for periodic outbreaks of murderous anti-semitism.

29 comments:

  1. Another great game! Love to see a some part of polish history in action :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I thought you would approve of a Polish victory!

      Delete
    2. Thank you, Michal - and me, too, Jon!

      Delete
  2. Troops and table look great, Keith. Good to see Russo-Polish collections out for battle and Julian back to hosting. An interesting conflict that I have only gamed at the operational level with hex-and-counter Wargames. Good stuff!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Jon, most of the troops ended up being Julians, although I did get to provide the "dismounts" too!

      Delete
  3. Excellent encounter, though a frontal assault with cavalry can have bloody consequences

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Scotty, I did try to explain that to Comrade Rick, who was all for me charging straight down the road at an HMG with my mounted cavalry.....!

      Delete
  4. Good looking game and nice to see the miniatures on the table, lovely collection they are too.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Donnie, I am glad you like the look of the table and figures!

      Delete
  5. Good to have Julian back I'm sure and great to see some more 1920's action, even if it was a tough old slog for the Soviet troops. Fine figures etc as always:).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, Steve, definitely good to have Jules back, although if he serves me up scenarios like this one too often, I might reconsider that opinion!

      Delete
  6. A nice game to celebrate Julian's return. Great to see you getting back into some Friday night games Keith.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Lawrence, it's certainly good to have Julian back...expect to see an increase in the number of games played!

      Delete
  7. Great looking game Keith.
    I hope that Julian brought back some souvenirs for you all. 😁
    Or at least some suitable wargame relevant photos.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Cheers Ben. Julian sent us quite a few pix during his trip, including from Corsica and Elba, which were Napoleon related...he also had some earlier from Greece relating to Alexander etc.

      Delete
  8. Fantastic stuff and interesting and often over looked period of history.
    Cheers
    Stu

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Cheers Stu....it certainly is an interesting period and even has some resonance with events today in Ukraine.....

      Delete
  9. Interesting period and good looking game, bit of a tough ask for the Soviets but it sounds like it went like the historical action in the end!
    Best Iain

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Iain! Julian's comment on the scenario was along the lines that "The Russians probbed with their cavalry all along the line, they would sweep in on horseback and if resistance was too stiff, they would just gallop off and try elsewhere"
      My comment at the start of the game was "We should just be galloping off go try elsewhere now!"
      I didn't really think we had much chance of winning this one!

      Delete
  10. Very interesting game Keith, its a period that you hardly ever see being played!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Cheers ray - certainly the Russo - Polish war is a pretty rare gaming period - probably because figures of Polish troops are pretty hard to come by! Julian got his in a bulk order from Siberia Miniatures about three years ago, just as the current war was kicking off - getting anything out of Russia nowadays might be quite hard, I imagine!

      Delete
  11. Without trying to be overly critical, but this scenario sounds rather lack luster if one side enters, gets shot to hell, and then exits. Might be realistic, but of no consequence unless part of a campaign.
    But the troops and terrain look pretty. 😁

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You might say that Stew.....I couldn't possibly comment! Your summation of our experience is pretty accurate though.

      Delete
  12. Great looking game with excellent figures, Keith. Love the militia irregulars!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks a lot Dean....the militia are certainly very characterful!

      Delete
  13. Tough task! Not really ideal cavalry country is it.
    Those Polish militia look great. In fact they all do.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Chris, and yes, it was a rather tricky situation for the Bolshevik cavalry....but glad you like all the pretty figures!

      Delete
  14. Almost missed this one! An under appreciated period but fascinating. Well done game with excellent figures and terrain. Wish I was there to Play this one!

    ReplyDelete
  15. A splendid looking game Keith….
    Headlong cavalry charges at HMG’s…?
    Not something I would ever do 🤣…
    A fascinating and colourful period…

    All the best. Aly

    ReplyDelete